In fact, when I got home and looked at the photo, I pretty much hated it.
But I wanted to love it. I really really wanted it to look like I had it in my head. But it was kind of awful. Rather than just deleting it, I decided to play around.
After looking at it a little more, and realizing that it would have been 1000 times better if all four girls had been looking off into the distance, I decided to treat it like an old-fashioned photo. You know those ones where no one is really looking at the camera, someone is grouchy, but it was all people had back in the day because film was expensive and photos were rare?
So, I converted it to black and white using a layer. I played around with the different options and chose "High Contrast Red." And then I decided I wanted a hint of color, so I set that layer at 75% opacity.
I liked the way it no longer looked like a bunch of girls squinting in the early morning sunlight, but I wanted to make it look grainy and old and well-worn, so I chose Calais from Love That Shot's Old World Collection. I added it at 75% opacity in overlay mode.
And because I am never satisfied and like big changes, I added one more layer for more oldness (is that a word?) and drama. I chose Sicily and added it at 45% opacity in linear burn mode.
It's not perfect, but I like how the sky looks moody, just like my daughter's face. If I edited it again, I might go ahead and remove all color from the photo. But that's the fun of digital photography, isn't it? You can just play and play.
If you have any thoughts, I'd love to hear them.